BCBA® task H.3 · Area H
H.3 Selecting socially valid replacement behaviors
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
When a plan reduces a behavior, it also names what the person will do instead. The replacement should be functionally equivalent: it produces the same reinforcer the problem behavior has been producing, so the person keeps access to something that matters to them. Prefer a response the person can acquire and access easily, with prompt and reliable reinforcement; effort, delay, quality and amount of reinforcement can trade off, so test actual response allocation rather than requiring an advantage on every dimension. It should also be socially valid: acceptable to the person and to the people around them, and likely to be noticed and reinforced in ordinary settings, not only during sessions.
Everyday example
An adult who uses few spoken words bangs on the kitchen counter when he wants coffee, and whoever is nearby usually makes some. A picture card he can hand to anyone in the kitchen, which gets coffee made just as quickly, gives him the same outcome with no extra effort. A long sentence he struggles to produce would lose to banging, which is faster.
Common confusion
An absence such as not hitting does not specify what to do to obtain a reinforcer. Sitting quietly or keeping hands down may be appropriate targets in a particular contingency, but do not assume they provide a functionally equivalent way to meet the need. Define the response, check that it is accessible and acceptable to the person, and verify what reinforcement it actually obtains. DRA can use other effective reinforcers, but functional equivalence is an important selection priority when replacing problem behavior.
Key points
- When a behavior is to be decreased, the alternative behavior should produce the same reinforcer that maintains it (functional equivalence).
- A socially valid alternative is acceptable to the client and stakeholders and is likely to be reinforced by natural contingencies in the client's everyday settings.
- To compete with the target behavior, the alternative should require no more response effort and pay off at least as quickly and reliably.
- Quiet compliance or the mere absence of the target behavior is not a replacement; the alternative adds a useful skill to the client's repertoire.
Examples from practice
Example 1
A girl whines for her parents' attention. She learns to tap a parent's arm and say 'Look!', which starts a short chat.
Example 2
A warehouse worker shoves boxes off a table to end a sorting task. He learns to press a 'pause' button that gives him a two-minute break.
Non-example
A boy hits to escape reading. The team reinforces completing puzzles with tokens. Puzzles are appropriate, but they give him no way to escape reading, so hitting still pays off.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
Assessment shows that a 5-year-old throws toys to get his brother to hand back a tablet. Which replacement is functionally equivalent?
-
Not quite. Tidying produces a sticker, not the tablet. It is appropriate but serves a different function.
-
Correct. The request produces the same reinforcer as throwing: access to the tablet.
-
Not quite. Sitting calmly is the absence of throwing and gives him no way to get the tablet.
-
Not quite. A hug is attention. The assessment points to access to the tablet.
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: B. Saying 'Tablet, please' to get the tablet back
- a. Tidying produces a sticker, not the tablet. It is appropriate but serves a different function.
- b. Correct. The request produces the same reinforcer as throwing: access to the tablet.
- c. Sitting calmly is the absence of throwing and gives him no way to get the tablet.
- d. A hug is attention. The assessment points to access to the tablet.
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area H All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.