BCBA® task H.2 · Area H
H.2 Choosing interventions from assessment, evidence, preference and context
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
Begin with the assessed needs, the evidence about relevant behavioral and contextual variables, and the goals the client values. For behavior reduction, evaluate maintaining consequences and select procedures that address the supported function; for skill acquisition, also assess prerequisites and useful learning opportunities. Integrate scientific evidence, client preferences and assent, family priorities, cultural variables and practical resources throughout selection. Research with similar learners and contexts informs a recommendation but does not guarantee this outcome. Check whether implementers have the skills, time and materials required. Prefer the least intrusive effective option, document the rationale for any greater restriction, and specify how outcomes, acceptability, safety and integrity will be monitored.
Everyday example
Two children both sweep materials off the table during seated work. A functional analysis shows that for one of them, sweeping ends the task; for the other, it reliably brings an adult over to chat. Same movement, two plans: the first child learns to ask for a short break while task demands are adjusted, and the second receives frequent attention while working and learns an acceptable way to call an adult.
Common confusion
Matching a procedure to the behavior’s form (“throwing calls for a point-loss system”) skips the function entirely. A procedure that succeeded in a well-staffed research study may still fail in a home with one tired parent and three other children; that is a problem of fit, not a reason to ignore evidence. And the fastest or most forceful option is not the default: restrictiveness has to be justified, never assumed.
Key points
- The function identified by assessment guides the choice: the intervention changes the reinforcement contingency that maintains the behavior rather than reacting to its form.
- Scientific evidence means research support for similar clients, behaviors and conditions; popularity, novelty, testimonials and anecdotes are not evidence.
- Among effective options, the client's preferences, assent and values (and those of caregivers) help decide which one to use.
- Contextual fit asks whether the people and setting can carry out the intervention as designed: implementer expertise and training, cultural variables, time, materials and other resources.
- The least restrictive and least intrusive procedure likely to be effective is recommended first; more restrictive procedures need a documented reason and risk review.
Examples from practice
Example 1
Two students tear up worksheets. For one, tearing ends the task; for the other, it brings a teacher over to talk. The first learns to ask for a short break; the second gets attention while working.
Example 2
A woman's loud complaints at home stop chores and are maintained by escape, so the plan teaches her to ask for a five-minute pause and shortens chores at first.
Non-example
A team adds a sticker chart for a boy's escape-maintained hiding under his desk because sticker charts work for many students. It may help, but nothing in it changes the escape contingency.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
A functional analysis supports escape from cleanup tasks as the reinforcer maintaining a man's spitting at a day program. Which plan addresses that function?
-
Not quite. Noncontingent attention suits attention-maintained behavior. Here the data point to escape from tasks.
-
Not quite. Sending him away after spitting ends cleanup and delivers escape, the reinforcer identified by the functional analysis.
-
Correct. The functional analysis identified escape. A break request gives an acceptable way to obtain that outcome, while demands increase gradually.
-
Not quite. This chooses by form. It ignores what maintains the spitting and adds a punishment procedure without a reason.
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: C. Teaching a break request as tasks build up gradually
- a. Noncontingent attention suits attention-maintained behavior. Here the data point to escape from tasks.
- b. Sending him away after spitting ends cleanup and delivers escape, the reinforcer identified by the functional analysis.
- c. Correct. The functional analysis identified escape. A break request gives an acceptable way to obtain that outcome, while demands increase gradually.
- d. This chooses by form. It ignores what maintains the spitting and adds a punishment procedure without a reason.
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area H All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.