BCBA® task G.17 · Area G

G.17 Punishment procedures

3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition

What it means

Punishment is a process defined by its effect: a consequence that makes the behavior it follows less likely. Positive punishment adds something, such as a reprimand, contingent exercise or overcorrection; restitutional overcorrection restores the environment beyond its earlier state, and positive practice repeats a correct form. Negative punishment removes access to reinforcement: time-out, exclusionary or not, and response cost, which removes a set amount of a reinforcer the person holds. Before recommending a restrictive or punishment procedure, document evidence that less intrusive approaches have not achieved the needed outcome. Any risk-based exception requires the existing intervention team to document a comparison of the danger to the client and the risks of the proposed procedure. Obtain informed consent and any required organizational or external review, seek assent as applicable, verify implementer competence, and reinforce useful alternatives. Set explicit outcome, adverse-effect and stopping criteria; promptly revise or end an ineffective or harmful procedure.

Everyday example

A student who marks his desk with a pen cleans his desk and two neighboring desks before recess (restitutional overcorrection). Over two weeks the marking becomes rare, and he earns praise and tokens for keeping his workspace clean. If the marking had not decreased, the procedure would not be functioning as punishment.

Common confusion

A procedure meant to be unpleasant is not punishment until the data show a decrease. Time-out depends on a reinforcing time-in, and for behavior maintained by escape it can deliver the very break the behavior was getting. Time-out removes access for a period; response cost removes a specific amount. When a reduction procedure is not working, review function, reinforcement and implementation before making it longer or stronger.

Key points

  • Positive punishment adds a stimulus or activity contingent on the behavior (for example reprimands, contingent exercise, overcorrection); negative punishment removes access to reinforcement (time-out, response cost). Either is confirmed only by a decrease in the behavior.
  • Time-out removes access to reinforcement for a period (nonexclusionary or exclusionary) and depends on a reinforcing time-in; it can reinforce behavior maintained by escape.
  • Response cost removes a specific amount of a reinforcer the learner has, such as tokens, and requires a reserve so that the learner does not go into debt; overcorrection can be restitutional (restoring the environment beyond its prior state) or positive practice (repeating a correct form).
  • Punishment procedures are considered after less restrictive options, combined with reinforcement of alternatives, applied immediately and consistently, and monitored with data and for side effects.

Examples from practice

Example 1

A youth soccer coach has a player who shoves opponents jog two laps of the field before returning to play, and shoving drops from four times per match to once. That is contingent exercise, a positive punishment procedure.

Example 2

A gaming café deducts ten minutes from a teenager's prepaid screen time each time he shouts at other players, and the shouting fades over two weeks. A removal followed by a decrease is negative punishment.

Non-example

A receptionist is scolded every time she arrives late, and her late arrivals rise from two to five per month. However unpleasant the scolding is, the data do not show punishment.

Check yourself

One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.

A school nurse reports that her stern lectures "punish" a student's visits to her office without symptoms. The visits rose from 3 to 7 per week after the lectures began. What is the most accurate conclusion?

Show the answer and the explanations

Answer: B. No punishing effect is shown; the lectures may even be reinforcing

  • a. Something is added, but positive punishment also requires a decrease. Visits went up.
  • b. Correct. Punishment is defined by a decrease in the behavior. An increase rules it out, and the attention in a lecture may be maintaining the visits; that function should be assessed.
  • c. The lecture is added, not a removal of access to reinforcement, and the visits did not decrease in any case.

The full lesson is in the course

The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.

Open the lesson Practice this task

Try a sample free, without an account

Key terms

Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.

All tasks in area G All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page

Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.