BCBA® task G.13 · Area G
G.13 Trial-based and free-operant teaching
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
Trial-based arrangements divide teaching into distinct opportunities, each with a beginning, a response opportunity and an outcome. In a free-operant arrangement, the response can recur without a new trial being initiated for each occurrence. This distinction concerns response opportunity, not whether teaching occurs at a table or during play, or whether the learner initiates an interaction. Naturalistic and incidental teaching can include discrete opportunities. Choose measures that answer the question: accuracy per opportunity, rate, latency, duration or independence may be relevant in either setting.
Everyday example
In one activity, an Instructor presents a picture, waits for a selection, records the outcome and removes the materials before the next trial. In another, an accessible sorting tray remains available for ten minutes, and the learner can place another item whenever ready, without waiting for a new adult-presented trial. The team records correct selections per trial in the first activity and independent placements per minute in the second.
Common confusion
Learner initiation and natural materials do not by themselves establish a free-operant arrangement. Inspect whether another response opportunity requires the next trial to begin. Select the measure for the behavior and decision, rather than assuming that all trial teaching uses only percent correct or all naturalistic teaching uses rate.
Key points
- Trial-based teaching (such as discrete trials) presents instructor-controlled learning opportunities, each with an SD, a response, a consequence and an intertrial interval; it is often summarized as percent correct.
- In free-operant arrangements, the learner can respond at any time and repeatedly, without a new trial for each response; behavior is often summarized as rate. Incidental and naturalistic teaching, often started by the learner, can be organized either way.
- Formats are chosen by goal: trial-based teaching gives many controlled opportunities for acquisition, while naturalistic teaching supports motivation, spontaneity and generalization; they are often combined.
- Each format is evaluated for its typical risks: rote or prompt-bound responding in trials, and too few learning opportunities when the environment is not arranged in free-operant teaching.
Examples from practice
Example 1
At the kitchen table, a parent sets out a spoon and a cup, says “Give me the cup,” praises a correct hand-off, notes it, and waits a few seconds before the next request.
Example 2
A job coach shows a new cashier one coin at a time, asks its value, gives feedback and pauses before the next coin; she reports 18 of 20, or 90% correct.
Non-example
A teen practicing typing during a 15-minute block, starting each word whenever ready, is not in trial-based teaching: no one starts each opportunity.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
A tutor shows a word card, says “Read,” gives a point for a correct reading, records it, and waits 3 seconds before the next card. The learner has up to 5 seconds to answer. How is this best classified?
-
Not quite. A response window inside a trial the tutor presents is still part of that trial. The learner cannot respond again until the next card.
-
Not quite. A reinforcer after a response appears in every format. Incidental teaching starts from the learner's interest; here the tutor starts every opportunity.
-
Correct. Card, response, point and pause form a discrete trial, and the tutor controls when each one begins.
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: C. Trial-based, since the tutor starts each opportunity
- a. A response window inside a trial the tutor presents is still part of that trial. The learner cannot respond again until the next card.
- b. A reinforcer after a response appears in every format. Incidental teaching starts from the learner's interest; here the tutor starts every opportunity.
- c. Correct. Card, response, point and pause form a discrete trial, and the tutor controls when each one begins.
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area G All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.