BCBA® task D.5 · Area D
D.5 Single-case versus group designs
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
Group designs often compare aggregated outcomes across groups assigned to different conditions, such as an intervention, another active intervention, usual care or no intervention; random assignment strengthens causal inference when feasible. They suit the question of how large an effect is, on average, across a population, which matters for program and policy decisions. Single-case designs show how each individual's behavior changes from session to session, and they let the investigator adjust conditions when the data call for it. Their generality comes from replication across individuals and settings, not from the number of people in one study.
Everyday example
A school district wants to know whether a reading program raises average scores across forty classrooms: a group comparison answers that. The Instructor deciding whether the same program is working for one particular child, and what to change if it is not, needs that child's repeated data.
Common confusion
An average can hide what happened to individuals: a modest mean gain may come from a few large improvements while many people did not change or got worse, and those results are not errors to discard. Neither family of designs is better for every question; pick the one that matches what you need to know.
Key points
- Single-case designs show how each individual's behavior changes and let the investigator adjust conditions in response to ongoing data.
- A group mean can hide individual variability: an average improvement may describe few or none of the participants.
- Group designs with random assignment and large samples are suited to estimating average effects across a population, such as for program or policy decisions.
- Single-case findings gain generality through replication across individuals and conditions, not through sample size.
Examples from practice
Example 1
A speech coach tries a pacing board with an adult who stutters; after a week of flat data she shortens the board and graphs the change as a new phase.
Example 2
A school picks a math program that raised average scores in a large trial, then tracks one student's problems solved each week to see whether it is working for him.
Non-example
A clinic reads that a parent-training program helped families on average and stops collecting data on its own client, assuming the average result will apply to him.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
A job coach wants to know whether a new task checklist is helping one employee, and to change it quickly if not. Which feature of single-case designs matters most here?
-
Not quite. Pooling across employees would not show whether the checklist helps this employee, and it delays the answer.
-
Not quite. A fixed protocol is typical of many group designs; the coach needs the freedom to adjust.
-
Correct. Repeated individual data reviewed as they come in let the coach see whether it works and adjust in a new phase.
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: C. Data are reviewed as they come in, so conditions can change
- a. Pooling across employees would not show whether the checklist helps this employee, and it delays the answer.
- b. A fixed protocol is typical of many group designs; the coach needs the freedom to adjust.
- c. Correct. Repeated individual data reviewed as they come in let the coach see whether it works and adjust in a new phase.
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area D All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.