BCBA® task D.3 · Area D
D.3 Threats to internal validity
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
A threat to internal validity is any uncontrolled factor that could produce, or hide, the change credited to the intervention. History is an outside event that happens to coincide with a change of condition. Maturation is change inside the person over time: growing older, tiring, recovering. Measurement threats include observer drift (an observer slowly applying the definition differently), observer expectancy, changes in instruments and reactivity, where being watched alters behavior. Sequence effects, regression toward the mean, participants dropping out and a procedure not carried out as written, which is poor treatment integrity, complete the usual list.
Everyday example
Tantrums drop in the very week a new plan starts, and in that same week the building work next door, which had been keeping the child awake, comes to an end. Better sleep from a quieter street is a history threat: an outside event lined up with the phase change. A toddler whose speech improves over six months of a program while also simply getting older illustrates maturation.
Common confusion
History happens outside the person; maturation happens inside the person and is tied to the passage of time. Regression toward the mean applies when someone was chosen because of an unusually extreme score, so a less extreme next measurement was likely anyway; it does not explain every improvement. Before crediting or blaming a treatment, check it was delivered as designed: poor integrity can hide a real effect or fake one.
Key points
- History is an event outside the study that coincides with a change in conditions and could produce the observed change.
- Maturation is change within the participant over time, such as development, growth or fatigue, that is independent of the procedure.
- Measurement- or observation-related threats include observer drift, expectancy, instrumentation changes and reactivity. Reactivity changes behavior itself; the others can alter its record.
- Sequence effects, regression toward the mean, attrition and poor treatment integrity can also produce or hide changes that are not due to the independent variable.
Examples from practice
Example 1
A man's calls to a crisis line drop the week a new treatment begins, which is also the week a long dispute with his landlord is settled: history.
Example 2
A toddler's unsupported steps increase through baseline and treatment at the same steady rate as she grows: maturation.
Non-example
A student's worry about tests eases after her school cancels final exams. That is not maturation: the change came from an outside event, not from growth within her.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
A teenager recovering from a broken wrist types steadily faster across baseline, and the rate of improvement stays the same when a typing program begins. Which threat is most relevant?
-
Correct. The improvement began in baseline and kept the same slope, which fits change within the person, such as healing, rather than an added treatment effect.
-
Not quite. History needs an outside event that coincides with the phase change. None is described, and the trend began before the program.
-
Not quite. Reactivity is a change caused by being observed. Nothing suggests observation changed, and the trend is steady from the start.
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: A. Maturation, such as healing as time passes
- a. Correct. The improvement began in baseline and kept the same slope, which fits change within the person, such as healing, rather than an added treatment effect.
- b. History needs an outside event that coincides with the phase change. None is described, and the trend began before the program.
- c. Reactivity is a change caused by being observed. Nothing suggests observation changed, and the trend is steady from the start.
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area D All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.