BCBA® task B.21 · Area B

B.21 Emergent relations and generative performance

3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition

What it means

Training some stimulus relations can be followed by the emergence of derived relations that were not directly trained; relevant learning history is still required. Reflexivity is demonstrated by untrained identity matching. Symmetry is demonstrated when training A→B is followed by untrained B→A responding. Transitivity is demonstrated when A→B and B→C training is followed by untrained A→C responding. Equivalence requires evidence that the relevant relations satisfy reflexivity, symmetry and transitivity. Generative performance also includes correct responses to untaught recombinations after selected combinations have been trained, as in matrix training. Derived relations can involve comparison or other relations beyond equivalence; relational frame theory analyzes such contextually controlled patterns.

Everyday example

Using physically dissimilar abstract symbols and several comparison choices, a learner is taught A→B and A→C. Without directly training B→C or C→B, probes assess whether those relations emerge. Each direction combines symmetry with transitivity. In matrix training, teaching “push the car” and “roll the ball” can be followed by correct responding to the untaught combination “push the ball”.

Common confusion

Symmetry reverses one relation; transitivity chains two. Matching a new photo of a dog because it looks like the trained one is stimulus generalization, not a derived relation. And recombining trained parts is generative performance, not transitivity.

Key points

  • Derived relations are demonstrated without direct training of those particular relations; their emergence depends on relevant learning history.
  • After A→B training, untrained B→A responding demonstrates symmetry. After A→B and B→C training, untrained A→C responding demonstrates transitivity. After A→B and A→C training, B→C and C→B probes combine symmetry with transitivity.
  • Generative performance: after a subset of combinations is trained (matrix training), learners can respond correctly to untaught recombinations of the trained components (recombinative generalization).
  • Derived relations go beyond equivalence: after some relations are trained (such as "more than," or speaker behavior), learners can derive untrained ones (such as "less than," or listener behavior, as in naming); multiple exemplar instruction can help establish this, and relational frame theory describes these patterns as relational frames.
  • Distinguish responding to new, physically similar exemplars (stimulus generalization) from untrained relations among stimuli (derived relations) and untaught combinations of trained components (recombinative generalization).

Examples from practice

Example 1

Symmetry: a new hire learns to select each unfamiliar manager's photo from several photos when shown that manager's new printed code. In untrained, no-feedback probes, a photo is the sample and she selects its matching code from several codes. The trained code→photo matching relation has reversed to photo→code.

Example 2

Transitivity: a traveler learns that a city code matches a city name, and that the city name matches its airport's photo. Untaught, he matches the code to the photo.

Non-example

A learner who was explicitly taught both "name → photo" and "photo → name" is not showing symmetry when she does both. Both directions were trained.

Check yourself

One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.

A, B and C label unfamiliar, physically dissimilar abstract symbols, not printed letters. With several comparison choices, Lucía learns A→B and B→C matching. In a no-feedback probe, she selects C when shown A, a relation not previously trained. Which property does that probe demonstrate?

Show the answer and the explanations

Answer: B. Transitivity

  • a. The probe tests a new relation among the trained, dissimilar stimuli, rather than responding to a new exemplar because it resembles a trained one. A→C follows the linked A→B and B→C training.
  • b. Correct. After A→B and B→C were trained, the untrained A→C relation emerged.
  • c. Symmetry reverses a single trained relation. A→C links two trained relations.
  • d. Reflexivity would be untrained identity matching, such as selecting A when the sample is A. This probe links A to a different stimulus, C, through the trained relations.

The full lesson is in the course

The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.

Open the lesson Practice this task

Try a sample free, without an account

Key terms

Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.

All tasks in area B All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page

Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.