BCBA® task B.17 · Area B
B.17 Motivating operations versus stimulus control
3 min read · BCBA® Test Content Outline, 6th edition
What it means
Both a discriminative stimulus and a motivating operation come before behavior, and both can make it more likely, but for different reasons. A discriminative stimulus signals that a reinforcer is available now if you respond. A motivating operation changes how much that reinforcer is worth now. Conditioned motivating operations include surrogate, reflexive and transitive functions. A surrogate CMO acquires motivating effects through pairing with another MO. A reflexive CMO changes the effectiveness of its own termination: a warning can make termination reinforcing, while a signal whose termination cancels an improvement can make termination punishing. These functions respectively evoke or abate behavior that previously terminated the signal. A transitive CMO changes the effectiveness of another stimulus through a learned dependency, such as a locked door making access to a key reinforcing.
Everyday example
You get home and the front door is locked. The locked door makes the key valuable and evokes asking for it: a transitive conditioned motivating operation. The key on the hook signals where to get it: that is stimulus control. A manager's "we need to talk," which has often come before bad news, can make ending the conversation reinforcing: a reflexive conditioned motivating operation.
Common confusion
Ask: does this stimulus tell me a reinforcer is available, or does it change how much I want it? The first is a discriminative stimulus, the second a motivating operation, and one stimulus can do both. Handing someone an item for free, over and over, does not by itself create a transitive motivating operation for asking for it.
Key points
- An SD concerns differential availability of reinforcement for a response; an MO concerns the current effectiveness of that reinforcement. The same stimulus can have both functions.
- Conditioned motivating functions depend on learning history. A surrogate CMO acquires effects through pairing with another MO. A reflexive CMO changes the effectiveness of its own termination as reinforcement or punishment: terminating a warning can prevent worsening, while terminating a signal of improvement can cancel that improvement. A transitive CMO changes the effectiveness of another stimulus through a learned dependency. Identify both the value-altering and current behavior-altering effects.
Examples from practice
Example 1
SD: a commuter buys coffee when the kiosk's shutter is up, because that is the only time coffee is sold.
Example 2
MO: the same commuter buys coffee more often after nights of poor sleep, at the same kiosk and the same price.
Non-example
A "Help available" light that is on only when the supervisor can answer is not an MO. It signals availability; it does not make help more valuable.
Check yourself
One question from the course lesson on this task. Choose an answer to see why it is right or wrong.
Lia asks a coworker for help mostly when he is at his desk, and rarely when he is away; the difficulty of her work is the same in both cases. His presence at the desk is best described as:
-
Not quite. Work difficulty, which would affect the value of help, is the same. His presence signals that help is available.
-
Correct. Asking pays off when he is there and not when he is away: differential availability.
-
Not quite. A reflexive CMO makes its own removal valuable. Nothing here is a warning or signal that Lia wants to end.
-
Not quite. Asking is operant, not a reflex elicited by his presence.
Show the answer and the explanations
Answer: B. A discriminative stimulus for asking
- a. Work difficulty, which would affect the value of help, is the same. His presence signals that help is available.
- b. Correct. Asking pays off when he is there and not when he is away: differential availability.
- c. A reflexive CMO makes its own removal valuable. Nothing here is a warning or signal that Lia wants to end.
- d. Asking is operant, not a reflex elicited by his presence.
The full lesson is in the course
The course lesson on this task goes further, with more sections, more examples and more practice questions, and keeps a record of what you have mastered.
Try a sample free, without an account
Key terms
Each term opens its definition in the ABA glossary.
All tasks in area B All 104 tasks ABA glossary: every term in one page
Independent study resource. INTERLAZA is not affiliated with or endorsed by the BACB. The explanations and examples are original, are not official exam content and do not reproduce any exam item.